Nobody likes flakes on their black jumpers. Or spending money on a new shampoo and realising it treats something your scalp doesn’t have a problem with.
There are lots of variations when it comes to anti Dandruff Shampoo. From regular washing of your hair, to medicated shampoo which has instructions to follow. This comparison looks at ingredients, how they may feel on the scalp and even packaging.
KinKind is the pick for those who want to reduce their amount of plastic in the bathroom, whilst still taking care of their scalp flakes. Below are other options to consider, if you would like a more specialised approach.
In This Guide
- How these shampoos compare
- KinKind
- Nizoral
- Head & Shoulders
- The Body Shop
- What to look for before buying
- Final verdict
How These Shampoos Compare
| Product | Suitable For | Main Ingredient | Packaging |
| KinKind | If you want to care for your scalp, but want to use less plastic | Propanediol caprylate | Shampoo Bar |
| Nizoral | More specialised treatment | Ketoconazole 2% | Treatment |
| Head & Shoulders | Scalp care, if itching is your biggest issue | Piroctone olamine, Aloe & Cactus Extract | Bottle |
| The Body Shop | Ginger scented, scalp care | Piroctone olamine, Ginger Root Oil | Bottle |
As you can see, these shampoos all do different things for your scalp. Especially if one is a treatment, and another is a shampoo bar that you would use regularly.
1. KinKind: Best for Plastic-Free, Everyday Anti-Dandruff Care
Shampoo can take care of your scalp, but not come in a bottle of plastic.

Clear my head! Anti Dandruff Shampoo by KinKind is designed for people dealing with dandruff, flaking, redness and itchiness. It uses propanediol caprylate, a naturally derived, plant-based ingredient, to help reduce flakes. KinKind describes it as a more environmentally friendly alternative to other anti Dandruff Shampoo ingredients, with research published on this ingredient in shampoo form.
Taking care of your scalp, with no excess plastic to throw away. You’ll smell like fresh apples, making it easy to use in your daily hair wash routine.
What makes it different?
- Less plastic: By using one bar you are replacing two bottles of shampoo, 250ml each.
- Useful: Can provide up to 50 washes, dependent on usage and how you store the product.
- Ethical: Vegan, Cruelty Free and Paraben Free.
- Plastic Free, Made in UK: Not only is the product plastic free, but the packaging is recyclable and the bar is made in the UK.
What does this do for your scalp? Your scalp has a mycobiome: the community of fungi, including yeasts, living on your scalp. Some of these organisms, i.e Malassezia (yeast) are linked to dandruff. They produce enzymes that break down propanediol caprylate, releasing caprylic acid, which in turn could regulate the mycobiome.
Research has been published on this ingredient, you can read up about the clinical trials done in anti-dandruff shampoo form. The published research does not establish that KinKind’s finished shampoo bar was itself clinically tested.
Simply apply to wet hair, lather and rinse away. KinKind states their foam cleanser is gentler than the cleanser in a leading bottled soothing anti-dandruff shampoo. Try to leave your KinKind bar somewhere it can air dry, this will allow it to last longer.
When wanting to change over from regular plastic haircare, KinKind is great because it has the ability to cleanse your scalp, smells nice and reduces your waste of disposable plastic bottles.
2. Nizoral: Best for a Medicated Treatment Routine
Sometimes you just want to choose a treatment that actually contains a medication to treat your dandruff.

Nizoral contains an anti fungal called Ketoconazole, this can be used to treat dandruff. The treatment is sold in the UK, as a 2% medication to be used for a period of time, rather than your everyday shampoo.
Containing a medication that targets your dandruff. If you have persistent flakes, and are wanting a treatment, rather than just a shampoo to wash your hair with, Nizoral could be an option.
Things to note:
- Contains 2% w/w ketoconazole in this treatment
- How long you use for, and how often, should be specified on the packaging.
- Sold in bottle form, rather than a bar.
It’s worth looking at, if your pharmacist suggests using an anti-fungal, as a treatment for your dandruff. However, it may not be suitable, if you’re trying to reduce your waste, of plastic bottles in your bathroom.
3. Head & Shoulders: Best for a Soothing Bottled Formula
Not only do you want to remove flakes from your scalp, but you want your shampoo to feel nice on your scalp, when washing your hair.

Head & Shoulders contain Piroctone Olamine, with additional ingredients such as aloe, cactus extract and Vitamin E. Their formula aims to target your dandruff, and the itching your scalp may produce.
You may want to try:
- It’s a normal bottle that you can use in your everyday life, to wash your hair.
- Contains ingredients that could soothe your scalp, i.e Aloe, Cactus Extract.
- As the name suggests, it’s for those with dandruff, and an itchy scalp.
The only downside, is you are still using a bottle, but this could be for your preference, when changing from your current haircare regime.
4. The Body Shop: Best for a Ginger-Led Scalp Routine
Maybe you like to smell of ginger, when washing your hair, or want to add more ginger to your haircare routine.

The Body Shop contains Piroctone Olamine, along with Ginger Root Oil. To target your flaky, dry scalp. There are more ginger products that you can buy, from The Body Shop, if you enjoy using their scent.
Part of the Body Shop, ginger range. If you like to use the same shampoo, conditioner, and scalp treatment, together, you can do so, with their range of ginger products.
There are multiple bottle sizes to choose from; the bottles can be recycled, where facilities allow.
What to Look for Before Buying
There are many reasons why you may have dandruff, including dry scalp, reactions to products or other conditions; poor hygiene is not a cause of dandruff. Before looking at scents, and plastic, figure out what you want from your shampoo.
- Check the ingredients, as mentioned above, there are different types of shampoo, and active ingredients, that you can use on your scalp.
- Make sure you know what type of shampoo you’re buying, whether it’s a treatment or a cosmetic anti-dandruff shampoo. Follow the instructions on the product you’ve bought. Here is Nizoral’s Medicines information.
- How will you store your shampoo? If it’s a bar, you’ll need somewhere that it can dry, after you have used it. Bottles will need shelf space, and produce more waste, once empty.
- Check if there are reviews for the product you’re considering.KinKind’s Trustpilot page shows, many customers have left reviews about using shampoo bars. However, these reviews do not guarantee that this anti-dandruff bar will work for everyone.
See a GP if your dandruff continues after at least 4 weeks of using anti-dandruff shampoo, or if your scalp is very itchy, red or swollen. You can find more information on the NHS website.
Final Verdict
All of the anti-dandruff shampoos have their pros and cons, depending on what you want from your shampoo. If you want to reduce the amount of plastic in your bathroom, KinKind is a great option for a daily-use anti-dandruff shampoo that smells like fresh apples and comes in recyclable packaging.


Head of Skincare Research & Development
Olivia M. writes the kind of advanced makeup formulations content that people actually send to each other. Not because it's flashy or controversial, but because it's the sort of thing where you read it and immediately think of three people who need to see it. Olivia has a talent for identifying the questions that a lot of people have but haven't quite figured out how to articulate yet — and then answering them properly.
They covers a lot of ground: Advanced Makeup Formulations, Everyday Beauty Hacks, Expert Breakdowns, and plenty of adjacent territory that doesn't always get treated with the same seriousness. The consistency across all of it is a certain kind of respect for the reader. Olivia doesn't assume people are stupid, and they doesn't assume they know everything either. They writes for someone who is genuinely trying to figure something out — because that's usually who's actually reading. That assumption shapes everything from how they structures an explanation to how much background they includes before getting to the point.
Beyond the practical stuff, there's something in Olivia's writing that reflects a real investment in the subject — not performed enthusiasm, but the kind of sustained interest that produces insight over time. They has been paying attention to advanced makeup formulations long enough that they notices things a more casual observer would miss. That depth shows up in the work in ways that are hard to fake.
